Dale Napier writer Tai Chi Chuan Tai Chi In Your Life Queen Joan politics martial arts cyberwar
Dale Napier writer Tai Chi Chuan Tai Chi In Your Life Queen Joan politics martial arts cyberwar
Dale Napier Writer Main Blog Dale Napier Writer Writings Readings Cyber Tai Chi
  
Tai Chi
Tai Chi Roots

24 Dec 2013
I'm not much for holiday TV fare, but today's showing of Roots, in all its flawed glory, was special. The show brings memories of thanks and of lessons learned about the study of the history that we care about, our own. At the end of the TV mini-series, when I learned Roots was a story that emerged from Alex Haley's personal quest, I thought, if the descendant of a slave can learn so much about his past, surely I can learn as much!

That was only five years after my father's premature death in 1972, so I grasped onto this idea and never let go. Over the next dozen years I slowly became the family historian, as I plugged into established family trees going back as far as 30 generations, to the 10th century C.E. and (later) the Norman Conquest.

I started the way anyone would start, with the family in front of me. My mother's parents were in their late 70s, in declining health, and lived in Dallas. The drive from Austin was an easy one, I went to visit them. I interviewed them for hours and wrote the results on a series of green five-by-eight index cards. I learned of three generations of my grandmother, and five generations of my grandfather. Eventually I would connect the maternal line to the only Union soldier in our otherwise very Southern family; I would connect the paternal line to the family tree of Lord Charles Spencer, brother of Princess Diana, which connected us to princes, prime ministers, earls, presidents, and a conqueror. I contacted my father's mother by phone and mail; she provided me with even more surprises.

That was long before the ascendancy of Ancestry.com, DNA testing, and the like. It was before the World Wide Web. Back then I had no clue how to proceed, so I put the index cards in a file folder and stuck the folder in my file cabinet, where it remained unmolested for a dozen years.

In 1989 I was working on a contract at Pennzoil where a co-worker, Tom Peacock, told me of the Clayton Genealogy Library. Only a few miles south of downtown, it is part of the Houston Library System and the best genealogy library in the South west of Atlanta. The Clayton Library opened me up to the world. It revived my interest in history. I took those index cards, still in that folder in my file cabinet, and went to work.

Genealogy library research involved reading old censuses on microfilm, after locating them through index searches. Even today the indexes vary greatly in quality from state to state and decade to decade. The work also involves visually scanning hundreds of books, by state and country, for references to your family. I am fortunate that my family tree is devoid of names like Smith, Jones, Johnson, or Garcia. Even a name like Napier has multiple sources, multiple interpretations, and many lines of descendancy - just enough to be interesting.

The details of my discoveries are interesting only to family members. The next part of my story involves the discovery that in writing Roots, Alex Haley lied. He made up stories. No doubt he had strands of facts and filled in the blanks, in order to create a story that could be told. I have lots of strands like that; occasionally I am tempted to posit a story of what might have happened - such as how 45-year-old Frenchman Jean Francois D'Autel, one of my father's maternal ancestors, ended up with a boatload (literally) of Germanic children, and left for Baltimore from Wurzburg in 1820. A Napoleonic soldier who went native in Germany and started life anew after being widowed? Perhaps.

To understand my reaction to this discovery, you have to understand me: I have a fact fixation. I want anything represented as fact to indeed be true. You give me a rule, and I struggle with attempts to finesse its meaning. Good thing I never became a lawyer!

Fiction - storytelling - need not be true, which is its great virtue, because ideas can be represented without being dragged down by reality. Reality is messy. A fiction writer can gloss over the rough edges with a clean conscience, if he chooses. Religious mythmaking often falls into this category, but then betrays its value, and worthiness, when portrayed as a depiction of something that really happened. At that point I lose respect for the storyteller. Learning is process of recognizing and abandoning delusions, so a delusional teacher is of little help.

In Haley's case, it wasn't my family history that he messed with. My takeaway was the value of getting to know your own roots, especially when circumstances have cut you away from them. For that lesson I salute Alex Haley.

The question of fact versus fiction resonates more deeply for me in other arenas, as it gets to the heart of questions of the history, and hence meaning, of Tai Chi Chuan - and ultimately, most religion as well. The origins of Tai Chi are as murky as the origins of man. Some historians and experts are close together despite disagreements, but others make wild claims that shatter any hope of closing in on the truth. Even within my own lineage, for which I am a lineage holder, I have been astonished to discover that some, perhaps most, of the stories of the last century cannot be true. I also uncovered a myth in my family's genealogy just three years ago. As long as I know they are myths, I have learned from the process of discovery. If I ignore that knowledge, I take a step backward.

Most recently, some Tai Chi and Qigong grandmasters have begun concocting new myths and fairy tales about the origins of Tai Chi and Qigong - not only contradicting most of the pre-existing stories without new evidence, but creating words and circumstances completely out of character with the times. It reminds me of Marvel Comics' periodic attempts to update their characters by rewriting their origin stories. Marvel's material is known to be fiction, but when a grandmaster speaks, people tend to take his words at face value, as they might a priest. This is how myths become regarded as truth, and truth evaporates like mist.

Why is that necessary? Why is it not sufficient that we drink deeply of an exercise form that seems to have no limit to mysteries and wonders? People make up untruths to cover for insecurities. Why should we feel the need to prove the value of Tai Chi with fictions? The value of Tai Chi lies in its fact.


You may also like this related article: The Full Life (149)
All Blogs
More Tai Chi blogs:
7 Feb 2016 Tai Chi What is an Internal Art?
30 Nov 2015 Tai Chi Rebooting Tai Chi
13 May 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #10: Stillness
13 Apr 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #9: Continuity
25 Mar 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #8: Unify Inner and Outer
13 Mar 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #7: Unify Your Body
22 Feb 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #6: Mind Over Matter
4 Feb 2015 Tai Chi Essential #5 - Drop the Shoulders
20 Jan 2015 Tai Chi Essential #4 - Full and Empty
13 Jan 2015 Tai Chi Feedback - Tai Chi Essentials 1-3
3 Jan 2015 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #3: Relax the Waist
26 Dec 2014 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #2: Sink Chest, Raise Back
18 Dec 2014 Tai Chi Tai Chi Essential #1: Crown Up
8 Dec 2014 Tai Chi The Essence of Tai Chi
22 Nov 2014 Tai Chi Do you Tinkle when you Tai Chi?
9 Nov 2014 Tai Chi Tai Chi and Music
28 May 2014 Tai Chi Tai Chi and Balance, Western Style
11 Nov 2013 Tai Chi Why Do We Train?
20 May 2013 Tai Chi Two Faces of Tai Chi
8 May 2013 Tai Chi Tai Chi in the Workplace
27 Apr 2013 Tai Chi World Tai Chi Day
10 Oct 2012 Tai Chi Deep Relaxation
19 Sep 2011 Tai Chi Tai Chi Ball
12 Sep 2011 Tai Chi Crashing the Wave
5 Sep 2011 Tai Chi Moving From the Waist
28 Jul 2011 Tai Chi Tai Chi vs. Qigong (Chi Kung)
16 Jun 2011 Tai Chi Practicing Too Much
1 May 2011 Tai Chi Practicing While Not Practicing
9 Mar 2011 Tai Chi Hiding it
13 Feb 2011 Tai Chi Tai Chi Community
2 Nov 2010 Tai Chi Accepting in Everyday Life
27 Oct 2010 Tai Chi Accepting in Martial Arts
5 Oct 2010 Tai Chi Neural Plasticity
14 Sep 2010 Tai Chi Dental Song
12 Jul 2010 Tai Chi Habit Forming
11 Jun 2010 Tai Chi Best Practices
17 May 2010 Tai Chi Morning Ritual
12 Apr 2010 Tai Chi Intention - Fantasy versus Reality
7 Mar 2010 Tai Chi Tai Chi Your Life
22 Jan 2010 Tai Chi Invest in Silence
13 Dec 2009 Tai Chi Steel Mist
22 Nov 2009 Tai Chi Crutches
12 Nov 2009 Tai Chi Tai Chi Recovery
22 Oct 2009 Tai Chi Illness as an Investment
1 Sep 2009 Tai Chi Indulge Yourself
28 Jul 2009 Tai Chi Illness and Tai Chi Challenges
16 Jul 2009 Tai Chi All Tai Chi Chuan is Good
7 Jul 2009 Tai Chi Training with the Grandmasters
19 Jun 2009 Tai Chi Zoning Out
8 May 2009 Tai Chi Form and Practice
5 Apr 2009 Tai Chi Tai Chi Friends Around the World
30 Mar 2009 Tai Chi The Yin and Yang of Season Change
22 Feb 2009 Tai Chi No Strain, No Gain
4 Feb 2009 Tai Chi No Pain, No Gain?
11 Jan 2009 Tai Chi Cheer Up!
19 Dec 2008 Tai Chi Gong Qi and Qi Gong
8 Dec 2008 Tai Chi Winter Solstice Celebration
2 Dec 2008 Tai Chi Accepting
20 Oct 2008 Tai Chi Acquiring without Seeking
7 Oct 2008 Tai Chi How to Not Focus on Focusing
15 Sep 2008 Tai Chi Elements Trump Class
3 Sep 2008 Tai Chi Fall Forward: Celebrate the Change of Seasons
8 Jul 2008 Tai Chi July Full Moon Observation
19 Jun 2008 Tai Chi Summer Solstice Celebration Friday
12 Jun 2008 Tai Chi What is Tai Chi?
12 May 2008 Tai Chi Tai Chi: The Next Generation
30 Apr 2008 Tai Chi Accepting
20 Apr 2008 Tai Chi First Steps in Tai Chi
5 Dec 2007 Tai Chi Tai Chi and Yoga
16 Nov 2007 Tai Chi Avoiding Carpal Tunnel Problems
18 Sep 2007 Tai Chi More Power of Intention
22 Aug 2007 Tai Chi Are you Continuous?
30 Jul 2007 Tai Chi Tai Chi Tournaments
2 Jul 2007 Tai Chi Healthy Tai Chi
30 May 2007 Tai Chi Continuity and Perseverance
13 May 2007 Tai Chi New Classes Added
27 Apr 2007 Tai Chi Observe World Tai Chi Day at the Houston Taoism Meetup
17 Apr 2007 Tai Chi Falls and Tai Chi
12 Apr 2007 Tai Chi The Important of Intention: Separating Fantasy from Reality
2 Apr 2007 Tai Chi "New Session"
26 Mar 2007 Tai Chi Coping with Grief and Sadness
24 Mar 2007 Tai Chi Missing Classes
20 Mar 2007 Tai Chi Spring and the Five Elements
13 Mar 2007 Tai Chi Tai Chi: Easy or Tough?
6 Mar 2007 Tai Chi My First Blog: A Message to Students After Their First Class
More Blog Categories:
Books (21)
Boulder City (10)
Culture (24)
Culture/TV (3)
Cyber (1)
Cyber / Military (2)
Energy/Environment (3)
Health & Fitness (4)
Money (1)
Politics (10)
Science (3)
Writing (4)